Cadenza
Loading...
Back to News
Data Investigation
The Orchestra Pay Gap
What CEOs, Conductors, and Musicians Actually Earn
Every number in this article comes from one of two public sources: IRS Form 990 filings — tax documents that every American nonprofit is legally required to file — and union contract announcements published by the American Federation of Musicians. The 990 data reflects fiscal years ending in 2024. The EIN for every organization is listed at the bottom of this article so that any reader can verify every figure independently.
Table of Contents (18 sections)
Highest Individual Pay
$2.78M
Gustavo Dudamel — LA Phil FY2024
Highest CEO Pay
$2.24M
Peter Gelb — Met Opera FY2024
Largest Pay Ratio
7.5 : 1
Cleveland CEO vs section musician
Met Opera Deficit
-$47.0M
While paying two people $4.3M
I. What the Conductors Earn
The music director is the artistic leader of an orchestra — the person on the podium, the face of the institution, the reason many subscribers buy their season tickets.
Music Director Total Compensation — IRS Form 990 (FY ending 2024)
Gustavo DudamelLA Philharmonic
$2,783,661Yannick Nézet-SéguinMetropolitan Opera
$2,072,060Franz Welser-Möst *Cleveland Orchestra
$1,713,698Andris Nelsons *Boston Symphony
~$1,700,000Jaap van Zweden *NY Philharmonic (final season)
~$1,500,000Juraj ValčuhaHouston Symphony
$648,524Riccardo MutiChicago Symphony (final season)
$628,175* Paid as independent contractor through management firm. Welser-Möst figure from Cleveland 990 contractor disclosure. Nelsons and van Zweden from press reporting. Nelsons was dismissed by the BSO in March 2026. Van Zweden departed the NY Phil in 2024. Muti is now Music Director Emeritus for Life. Dudamel begins at the NY Philharmonic in September 2026.
Gustavo Dudamel earned $2,783,661 in total compensation during his final season as Music Director of the Los Angeles Philharmonic. He begins as Music Director of the New York Philharmonic in September 2026.
Yannick Nézet-Séguin earned $2,072,060 in total compensation from the Metropolitan Opera ($2,045,038 reportable + $27,022 other). His reportable compensation rose 56% from the prior year's $1,307,583. He simultaneously holds the music directorship of the Philadelphia Orchestra, where his compensation is paid through a management firm and does not appear in the standard employee disclosure.
Riccardo Muti's $628,175 reflects a reduced schedule during his transition to Music Director Emeritus for Life. In prior seasons, Muti reportedly earned over $3 million annually from the CSO.
II. What the CEOs Earn
The CEO or president manages the business side of an orchestra: fundraising, board relations, operations, and financial strategy. They do not perform on stage.
CEO / President Total Compensation — IRS Form 990 (FY ending 2024)
Peter GelbMetropolitan Opera
$2,237,377Deborah BordaNY Phil (now President Emerita)
$1,818,409Gail SamuelBoston Symphony (departed Dec 2022)
$1,717,195André GremilletCleveland Orchestra
$1,167,666Matías TarnopolskyPhiladelphia (now NY Phil CEO)
$1,072,718Chad SmithLA Phil (now BSO President & CEO)
$1,019,386Gary GinstlingNY Phil (now Houston Symphony CEO)
$970,994Jeff AlexanderChicago Symphony
$953,469Kim NoltemyDallas (now LA Phil CEO)
$796,491Matthew SpiveySan Francisco Symphony
$773,823Melia TourangeauPittsburgh Symphony
$534,178Michelle Miller BurnsMinnesota (now Dallas CEO)
$519,477John MangumHouston (now Lyric Opera Chicago)
$494,853Erik RonmarkDetroit Symphony
$445,125Total compensation = base salary + other reportable compensation from IRS Form 990 Part VII. Parenthetical notes indicate role changes since the filing period. Gail Samuel departed the BSO in December 2022; her FY2024 compensation likely includes severance or deferred pay.
Peter Gelb, the Metropolitan Opera's General Manager, earned $2,237,377 in total compensation — $1,395,216 in base salary plus $842,161 in “other compensation.” The Met reported a $47.0 million operating deficit in the same filing year.
Deborah Borda earned $1,818,409 from the New York Philharmonic in a transitional “Executive Advisor” role after stepping down as CEO. She has since been named President Emerita.
Gail Samuel earned $1,717,195 from the Boston Symphony Orchestra despite having departed the CEO role in December 2022. The BSO reported a $6.6 million deficit in the same filing. The BSO's current CEO, Chad Smith — who also appears on the LA Philharmonic's 990 at $1,019,386 for his final year there — fired Music Director Andris Nelsons in March 2026, citing financial concerns.
III. The Musical Chairs
Five of the fourteen CEOs in this analysis left their orchestras within a year of these filings. Several moved directly to peer institutions — in some cases replacing each other in a chain.
Who Moved Where Since These Filings
Matías TarnopolskyPhiladelphia Orchestra CEONY Philharmonic CEO (Jan 2025)$1,072,718 at Philly
Gary GinstlingNY Philharmonic CEOHouston Symphony CEO (Feb 2025)$970,994 at NY Phil
Kim NoltemyDallas Symphony CEOLA Philharmonic CEO (Jul 2024)$796,491 at Dallas
Michelle Miller BurnsMinnesota Orchestra CEODallas Symphony CEO (Sep 2024)$519,477 at Minnesota
John MangumHouston Symphony CEOLyric Opera of Chicago (Fall 2024)$494,853 at Houston
Chad SmithLA Philharmonic CEOBoston Symphony CEO (2023)$1,019,386 at LA Phil
Gustavo DudamelLA Phil Music DirectorNY Phil Music Director (Sep 2026)$2,783,661 at LA Phil
IV. What the Musicians Earn
These are the people the audience comes to hear. The figures below represent the minimum annual base salary for a section musician — not a principal, not a concertmaster, but the floor of what each orchestra pays the rank-and-file performers who fill the stage.
Musician Minimum Base Salary — Current Union Contracts
San Francisco Symphonyby final yr (2027)
$205,920New York Philharmonicby final yr (2026–27)
$205,000Boston Symphony2025–26
~$203,000Los Angeles Philharmonic2025–26
>$200,000Chicago Symphony2025–26
~$198,000Philadelphia Orchestraby yr 3
~$176,000National Symphony Orchestrayr 2
$171,879Cleveland Orchestraest.
~$155,000Pittsburgh Symphonyby yr 3 (2027)
$124,020Cincinnati Symphony2024–25
$122,087Seattle Symphony2023–24
$121,816Detroit Symphonyest. by yr 3
~$116,000Verified sources: SFS press release (2024), AFM Local 802 (2024), AFM Local 47 (2025), WFMT & CSO.org (2023), CBS Philadelphia (2023), Kennedy Center (2024), International Musician, All is Yar contract comparison (2025), Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (2024), Symphony.org, Seattle Symphony, Detroit News (2024). “By yr 3” / “by final yr” indicates the final year of the current contract. “Est.” figures calculated from announced percentage increases on confirmed base figures. Figures marked “~” are approximate. Minnesota Orchestra excluded due to insufficient public sourcing for current base.
The San Francisco Symphony now pays the highest base salary in America at $205,920. The New York Philharmonic and Los Angeles Philharmonic have followed suit, both approaching or exceeding $200,000.
The Boston Symphony Orchestra — with $618 million in net assets, the largest of any orchestra in this analysis — pays its section musicians approximately $203,000. Despite this wealth, the BSO ran a $6.6 million deficit and fired its Grammy-winning Music Director in March 2026, citing financial concerns.
V. The Gap
Each card shows the highest-paid executive at a given orchestra (total compensation from 990 Part VII: base + other reportable compensation) alongside the minimum base salary for a section musician (from union contracts). Note: musician total compensation — including health insurance, pension, per-service pay, and seniority — is typically 20–40% above the base figure. The ratios below compare executive total compensation to musician base salary, not total-to-total.
Metropolitan Opera
General Manager
Peter Gelb
$2,237,377
Musician Base
Section minimum
*
Ratio
—
⚠ Deficit: -$47.0M
Boston Symphony
Former CEO
Gail Samuel (departed)
$1,717,195
Musician Base
Section minimum
~$203K
Ratio
8.5:1
⚠ Deficit: -$6.6M
Cleveland Orchestra
President & CEO
André Gremillet
$1,167,666
Musician Base
Section minimum
~$155K
Ratio
7.5:1
▲ Surplus: +$7.6M
Philadelphia Orchestra
Former CEO (now NY Phil)
Matías Tarnopolsky
$1,072,718
Musician Base
Section minimum
~$176K
Ratio
6:1
▲ Surplus: +$19.6M
Chicago Symphony
President
Jeff Alexander
$953,469
Musician Base
Section minimum
~$198K
Ratio
4.8:1
▲ Surplus: +$36.8M
Dallas Symphony
Former CEO
Kim Noltemy (now LA Phil)
$796,491
Musician Base
Section minimum
~$107K
Ratio
7.4:1
⚠ Deficit: -$7.4M
Pittsburgh Symphony
President & CEO
Melia Tourangeau
$534,178
Musician Base
Section minimum
$124K
Ratio
4.3:1
▲ Surplus: +$12.5M
Detroit Symphony
President & CEO
Erik Ronmark
$445,125
Musician Base
Section minimum
~$116K
Ratio
3.8:1
⚠ Deficit: -$8.0M
* Met Opera musician base salary is not available via published union contract. Slippedisc reported in July 2025 that a 25-year Met veteran earns less today than in 2011.
At the Metropolitan Opera, the General Manager earned $2,237,377 and the Music Director earned $2,072,060 — combined compensation of $4.3 million — at an organization that lost $47 million.
At the Dallas Symphony, the CEO earned 7.4 times the estimated musician base — at an orchestra that lost $7.4 million and holds only $6.5 million in net assets.
At the Detroit Symphony, the CEO earned 3.8 times the musician base — at an orchestra with negative net assets of −$10.2 million.
This data is public. Share it. cadenza.work/news/orchestra-pay-gap
VI. The Concertmaster Test
The concertmaster is the highest-paid musician in an orchestra. If any musician's compensation should approach executive territory, it is the concertmaster. At every orchestra below, the CEO earns more.
Concertmaster vs. CEO — Same Orchestra, Same Filing Year
New York Philharmonic
Deborah Borda (Exec Advisor)CEO / President
$1,818,409Frank HuangConcertmaster
$749,212Gap: $1,069,197
Philadelphia Orchestra
Matías Tarnopolsky (CEO)CEO / President
$1,072,718David KimConcertmaster
$510,730Gap: $561,988
Chicago Symphony
Jeff Alexander (President)CEO / President
$953,469Robert ChenConcertmaster
$645,786Gap: $307,683
San Francisco Symphony
Matthew Spivey (CEO)CEO / President
$773,823Alexander BarantschikConcertmaster
$652,984Gap: $120,839
Los Angeles Philharmonic
Chad Smith (Former CEO)CEO / President
$1,019,386Martin ChalifourConcertmaster
$598,812Gap: $420,574
CEO / President Concertmaster — All figures from IRS Form 990 Part VII, same filing year.
Frank Huang — concertmaster of the New York Philharmonic, one of the most accomplished violinists in the world — earned less than half of what an executive advisor earned at the same organization in the same year. The gap: $1,069,197.
VII. The Finances
Of the thirteen orchestras in this analysis, six reported operating deficits and seven reported surpluses.
Revenue vs. Expenses — IRS Form 990 (Most Recent Filing)
Metropolitan Opera$284.0Mvs$331.0M-$47.0M
SF Symphony$67.8Mvs$84.6M-$16.8M
Detroit Symphony$40.7Mvs$48.7M-$8.0M
Dallas Symphony$41.6Mvs$49.0M-$7.4M
Boston Symphony$117.1Mvs$123.7M-$6.6M
Minnesota Orchestra$38.7Mvs$45.0M-$6.3M
Houston Symphony$38.8Mvs$36.9M+$1.8M
LA Philharmonic$216.7Mvs$210.3M+$6.4M
Cleveland Orchestra$79.4Mvs$71.8M+$7.6M
Pittsburgh Symphony$55.2Mvs$42.7M+$12.5M
NY Philharmonic$113.9Mvs$96.2M+$17.7M
Philadelphia Orchestra$84.4Mvs$64.8M+$19.6M
Chicago Symphony$125.5Mvs$88.6M+$36.8M
Total revenue minus total expenses from IRS Form 990 Part I. Sorted by result (deficits first). Does not include unrealized investment gains or losses. Houston Symphony has negative net assets of −$10.2M. Dallas Symphony holds only $6.5M in net assets.
VIII. Orchestra Wealth vs. What Musicians Earn
Net assets represent an orchestra's total wealth — endowments, property, investments, minus liabilities. This is the institution's financial foundation. How does that wealth relate to what the musicians on stage actually earn?
Net Assets vs. Musician Base Salary
Boston Symphony$618.4M~$203K
LA Philharmonic$536.2M>$200K
NY Philharmonic$497.9M$205K
Chicago Symphony$420.3M~$198K
SF Symphony$404.5M$206K
Cleveland Orchestra$324.3M~$155K
Philadelphia Orchestra$209.8M~$176K
Minnesota Orchestra$185.6MN/A
Met Opera$180.2MN/A
Pittsburgh Symphony$163.9M$124K
Detroit Symphony$108.9M~$116K
Dallas Symphony$6.5MN/A
Houston Symphony-$10.2MN/A
Net Assets Blue = Musician Base Houston has negative net assets.
The Boston Symphony holds $618 million in net assets — the largest war chest in American orchestral music. The Cleveland Orchestra holds $324 million but pays its musicians approximately $155,000 — less than Pittsburgh's $124,020 only in ratio terms, but significantly less than peers with comparable or smaller asset bases.
IX. The International Lens
How do American orchestra pay structures compare to Europe's most prestigious ensembles? The gap is not in what musicians earn — it's in the ratio between executive and musician compensation.
United States
Private nonprofit model — donor-funded
Avg. CEO Pay~$945K
Top Music Director$2.78M
Avg. Section Musician~$170K
CEO : Musician Ratio5.6 : 1
Germany
Publicly funded model — state/city supported
Intendant (Managing Dir.)~€150–200K *
Chief Conductor~$500K–$1M
Avg. Section Musician~€102K
Intendant : Musician Ratio1.9 : 1
A Berlin Philharmonic tutti musician earns approximately €114,000 gross (~$125,000 USD) according to the Deutsche Orchestervereinigung. The Berlin Phil's Intendant salary is not publicly disclosed, but German public-sector cultural leadership positions at this level are typically in the €150,000–€200,000 range — a fraction of what comparable US executives earn.
At the Los Angeles Philharmonic, a section musician earns over $200,000. The former CEO earned $1,019,386. The Music Director earned $2,783,661. The CEO-to-musician ratio: 5.1 to 1. The conductor-to-musician ratio: 13.9 to 1.
American musicians are paid more in absolute terms. But the ratio between executive compensation and musician compensation is far wider in the American private-funding model than in Europe's publicly funded system.
European Orchestra Musician Pay (Gross Annual, Tutti Players)
Berlin PhilharmonicGermany — DOV 2019
€114,000Bavarian State OrchestraGermany — DOV 2019
€89,000Leipzig GewandhausGermany — Slippedisc 2018 (€5,700/mo)
~€68,400Royal ConcertgebouwNetherlands — player-reported 2018 (€5,040/mo)
~€60,480BBC SymphonyUK — August 2025 agreement
£41,104All figures are gross (before tax). German figures from the Deutsche Orchestervereinigung (DOV), reported by Slippedisc (2018, 2019). BBC figure from the August 2025 union agreement reported by Slippedisc and Arts Professional. Concertgebouw figure from a 20-year veteran tutti player writing on Slippedisc (2018). Monthly figures annualized (×12). German musicians may receive a 13th-month salary and holiday bonuses not reflected here.
The Ratio Comparison
Germany (Berlin Phil)~€190K *vs€114K1.7x
UK (BBC Symphony)N/Avs£41K—
USA (13-orchestra avg)$945Kvs~$170K5.6x
USA (Cleveland)$1.17Mvs~$155K7.5x
USA (Met Opera, GM)$2.24MvsN/A—
* German Intendant salary estimated from public sector pay scales — not independently verified. Berlin Phil does not publish executive compensation. BBC executive pay not separately broken out from BBC corporate. US figures from IRS Form 990 filings. Ratios compare top executive to section musician base.
Sources: Deutsche Orchestervereinigung (DOV) salary data reported by Slippedisc (2018, 2019). BBC salary from August 2025 agreement (Slippedisc, Arts Professional). Concertgebouw figure from player testimony (Slippedisc 2018). All European figures are gross before tax and subject to currency fluctuation. EUR/USD rate ~1.10, GBP/USD rate ~1.27 as of April 2026. German Intendant salary range is an estimate from public-sector pay scales, not a confirmed figure.
X. The Training Investment
What does it take to win a section seat in a major American orchestra?
15–25
Years of Training
From first lesson to winning a seat
$232K
Juilliard Tuition
4-year bachelor's degree at $58K/yr
100–300
Applicants per Seat
Some positions draw 500+
10,000+
Hours of Practice
Before the first professional audition
Path to a Section Seat
1
Private lessons begin
Age 5–10
2
Youth orchestra, competitions
Age 12–17
3
Bachelor's degree (conservatory)
Age 18–22
4
Master's degree
Age 22–24
5
Fellowships, freelancing
Age 24–30
6
Win an audition
Age 25–35
Education Cost (2024–25)
Juilliard4-year total
$232,000New England Conservatory4-year total
$243,000Manhattan School of Music4-year total
~$220,000Curtis Institute of Music4-year total
$0 (tuition-free)Colburn School4-year total
$0 (tuition-free)Many musicians also complete a master's degree (2 years, $60K–$120K additional) or doctoral program. Most fund their education through a mix of scholarships, loans, and teaching. Compare tuition across all major conservatories and music schools on Cadenza's tuition comparison tool.
A typical section musician has invested $200,000–$400,000 in education and 20+ years of daily practice to earn a seat that pays $116,000–$206,000. A typical orchestra CEO path includes a bachelor's degree (often in arts administration or business), possibly an MBA, and 10–15 years of professional experience.
Tuition data from Juilliard, NEC, and MSM published tuition schedules (2024–25). Curtis and Colburn are tuition-free institutions. Audition statistics from orchestra HR departments and press reporting. Practice hour estimates from music performance research literature.
XI. What the Principal Players Earn
Beyond the concertmaster, here are the highest-paid musicians at each orchestra — the principal players who lead their sections. All figures from IRS Form 990 Part VII (total compensation: reportable + other).
New York Philharmonic
Frank HuangConcertmaster
$749,212Anthony McGillPrincipal Clarinet
$545,162Liang WangPrincipal Oboe
$535,542Carter BreyPrincipal Cello
$498,785Chicago Symphony
Robert ChenConcertmaster
$645,786Esteban BatallánPrincipal Trumpet
$407,070Stephen WilliamsonPrincipal Clarinet
$408,828John SharpPrincipal Cello
$404,251San Francisco Symphony
Alexander BarantschikConcertmaster
$652,984Eugene IzotovPrincipal Oboe
$393,250Edward StephanPrincipal Timpani
$347,550Rainer EudeikisPrincipal Cello
$333,059Boston Symphony
Timothy GenisTimpani
$348,305John Ferrillo JrPrincipal Oboe
$371,701Alexander VelinzonAssoc. Concertmaster
$369,876Richard SebringPrincipal Horn
$353,661Philadelphia Orchestra
David KimConcertmaster
$510,730Ricardo MoralesMusician
$439,975Jennifer MontoneMusician
$379,015Jeffrey KhanerMusician
$375,735Metropolitan Opera Orchestra
David ChanConcertmaster
$559,817Benjamin BowmanConcertmaster
$468,062Donald PalumboChorus Master
$623,898All figures from IRS Form 990 Part VII (reportable + other compensation). Principal players are the section leaders — the highest-paid musicians after the concertmaster. Not all orchestras disclose individual musician compensation on the 990; only those earning above the reporting threshold appear.
XII. What Is “Other Compensation”?
Peter Gelb's 990 lists $1,395,216 in reportable compensation and $842,161 in “other compensation.” What does that mean?
IRS Form 990, Schedule J — Compensation Categories
Base Compensation
Salary, fees, bonuses, and severance reported on W-2 or 1099
Retirement & Deferred Comp
Contributions to retirement plans, deferred compensation payouts, supplemental executive retirement plans (SERPs)
Nontaxable Benefits
Health insurance, housing allowances, life insurance, employer-provided vehicles, club memberships
First-Class Travel
Schedule J asks whether the org provided first-class or charter travel for any officer — multiple orchestras in this analysis checked "Yes"
Tax Gross-Ups
The organization pays the executive's personal taxes on certain benefits — effectively increasing compensation by covering tax liability
Housing
Employer-provided residences or housing allowances — particularly relevant for music directors who maintain homes in multiple cities
“Other compensation” in Part VII combines columns E and F. The full breakdown is on Schedule J, which is part of the complete 990 filing available on ProPublica. The orchestras in this analysis that reported providing first-class or charter travel include the Boston Symphony, Chicago Symphony, Cleveland Orchestra, LA Philharmonic, and Metropolitan Opera.
XIII. Look Up Your Orchestra
Every orchestra in this article links directly to its IRS filing on ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer. You can look up any nonprofit in America — including your own orchestra.
Direct Links to IRS Form 990 Filings
Metropolitan OperaLA PhilharmonicBoston SymphonyNY PhilharmonicChicago SymphonyCleveland OrchestraSF SymphonyPhiladelphia OrchestraPittsburgh SymphonyMinnesota OrchestraDetroit SymphonyHouston SymphonyDallas Symphony
How to look up any orchestra:
- 1. Go to projects.propublica.org/nonprofits
- 2. Search for the orchestra by name
- 3. Click the most recent filing year
- 4. Scroll to “Compensation of Officers” to see executive pay
- 5. Click “Full Filing” to download the complete 990 with Schedule J details
Every US nonprofit with gross receipts over $200,000 is required to file a Form 990 and make it publicly available. This is federal law (26 USC § 6104). The data is not leaked, hacked, or confidential. It is public information that every taxpayer has a right to inspect.
Share This Data
IRS Form 990 Data — America's Top Orchestras
Highest-paid individual
$2,783,661
Gustavo Dudamel — Music Director, LA Philharmonic
Highest-paid CEO
$2,237,377
Peter Gelb — General Manager, Metropolitan Opera
At an organization that lost $47 million
Musician base salary range
$116K – $206K
Section minimum — Detroit to San Francisco
Source: IRS Form 990 filings & AFM union contracts
cadenza.work/news/orchestra-pay-gap
XIV. The Cost of Raising Money
Every orchestra in this analysis depends heavily on donations. How much does it cost each one to raise a dollar? The IRS Form 990 Part IX breaks expenses into three categories: program services, management, and fundraising. Here is what each orchestra spends on fundraising relative to what it brings in.
Most Efficient
Chicago Symphony
6.3¢
to raise each dollar
Raised
$71.5M
$71.5M
Spent
$4.5M
$4.5M
Least Efficient
Dallas Symphony
33.3¢
to raise each dollar
Raised
$12.6M
$12.6M
Spent
$4.2M
$4.2M
For every $3 raised, $1 went to the cost of raising it
All 13 Orchestras — Cost per Dollar Raised
Chicago Symphony
$71.5M raised · $4.5M spent6.3¢
Pittsburgh Symphony
$33.8M raised · $2.5M spent7.5¢
Philadelphia Orchestra
$31.6M raised · $2.7M spent8.7¢
Cleveland Orchestra
$46.9M raised · $4.2M spent9.0¢
Metropolitan Opera
$152.6M raised · $14.8M spent9.7¢
Minnesota Orchestra
$26.7M raised · $3.1M spent11.6¢
Detroit Symphony
$28.8M raised · $3.4M spent11.7¢
NY Philharmonic
$67.9M raised · $8.4M spent12.3¢
Houston Symphony
$27.2M raised · $4M spent14.9¢
LA Philharmonic
$45.9M raised · $7.6M spent16.5¢
Boston Symphony
$37.1M raised · $7.2M spent19.5¢
SF Symphony
$26.5M raised · $5.4M spent20.5¢
Dallas Symphony
$12.6M raised · $4.2M spent33.3¢
Fundraising expenses from 990 Part IX, Column D, Line 25. Total contributions from Part VIII, Line 1h. Sorted by efficiency. Green = under 15¢. Amber = 15–25¢. Red = over 25¢. Charity Navigator considers under 20¢ as efficient.
The Metropolitan Opera raised $152.6 million — by far the most in this analysis — at a cost of 9.7 cents per dollar. Scale matters: a large, established donor base costs less per dollar to maintain than a small one.
XV. When Musicians Fought Back
Several of the orchestras in this analysis have experienced strikes or lockouts in the past fifteen years. In each case, musician compensation was the central issue.
2010
Detroit Symphony
View on CadenzaStrike — 6 months
Musicians accepted ~25% pay cut (from ~$105K to ~$79K). Base salary in 2025 (~$110K) is barely above 2010 pre-strike levels after 15 years.
2012–14
Minnesota Orchestra
View on CadenzaLockout — 15 months
Management locked out musicians for over a year. Musicians accepted cuts from ~$135K to ~$118K. Music Director Osmo Vänskä resigned in protest.
2014
Atlanta Symphony
Lockout — 8 weeks
Management locked out musicians citing financial distress. Musicians accepted concessions. The Woodruff Arts Center CEO earned $528,400 in the most recent filing.
2016
Pittsburgh Symphony
View on CadenzaStrike — 2 weeks
Central issue: management proposed converting the defined-benefit pension to a 401(k)-style plan, shifting long-term risk to musicians.
2019
Chicago Symphony
View on CadenzaStrike — 7 weeks
Longest CSO strike in history. Key issue: pension. Musicians won — preserved defined-benefit plan. Base salary rose to $181,272. CEO Jeff Alexander earned $953,469 in the filing year.
2024
National Symphony
Strike — brief
Musicians struck briefly in September 2024. Settled with raises to $171,879 in year 2.
Sources: Press reporting from the Detroit News, Star Tribune (Minneapolis), Atlanta Journal-Constitution, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Chicago Tribune, and WTOP (Washington). Salary figures from union announcements and IRS Form 990 filings.
The pension issue recurs. In Chicago, Pittsburgh, and other negotiations, management's primary target has been converting defined-benefit pensions — which guarantee a fixed retirement income — to defined-contribution plans (401k-style), which shift investment risk from the institution to the individual musician. This represents an enormous long-term cost transfer, even when base salaries appear stable or growing.
XVI. Explore These Orchestras on Cadenza
Every orchestra in this article has a profile on Cadenza with current listings, programs, and organization details.
XVII. Methodology
Executive Compensation
All executive and key employee compensation figures are drawn from IRS Form 990, Part VII, as reported on ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer. Total compensation = Column D (reportable compensation from the organization) + Column E (reportable compensation from related organizations) + Column F (estimated amount of other compensation from the organization and related organizations). Where only reportable compensation was available, this is noted. Some music directors (Nelsons, Welser-Möst, Nézet-Séguin at Philadelphia) are paid as independent contractors; their compensation appears in Part IX or Schedule J rather than Part VII. These figures are marked with an asterisk and sourced from press reporting.
Musician Salaries
Musician base salaries are drawn from published union contract announcements by the American Federation of Musicians and its local chapters, press releases from the orchestras themselves, and press reporting of contract terms. These represent the minimum annual base salary for a section (tutti) musician — the floor of compensation. Total musician compensation, including health insurance, pension contributions, per-service pay, seniority supplements, and summer festival income, is typically 20–40% above the base figure. The ratios in this article compare executive total compensation to musician base salary. This is an apples-to-oranges comparison that we acknowledge transparently.
Financial Data
Revenue and expense figures are from IRS Form 990 Part I (Summary). “Surplus” and “deficit” refer to total revenue minus total expenses as reported on the 990. This does not include unrealized investment gains or losses, which can significantly affect an organization's financial position. Net assets are from Part I, Line 22.
What This Article Does Not Claim
This article does not claim that any individual is overpaid or underpaid. It does not claim that any orchestra is mismanaged. It does not attribute motive to any compensation decision. It presents publicly available data in a structured format and allows readers to draw their own conclusions. Some executive compensation figures include severance or transitional payments (notably Gail Samuel at the BSO and Deborah Borda at the NY Phil), which are one-time events and do not represent ongoing CEO compensation at those orchestras.
European Data
European salary figures are from the Deutsche Orchestervereinigung (DOV) as reported by Slippedisc (2018, 2019), the BBC Musicians' Union agreement (August 2025), and player-reported data. German Intendant salary ranges are estimates from public-sector pay scales, not confirmed figures. European data is less standardized than US 990 data because European orchestras are not subject to equivalent public disclosure requirements.
XVIII. The Numbers
This article draws no conclusions. Every figure comes from a public tax filing or a published union contract. The IRS Form 990 is a legal document — the orchestras themselves reported these numbers to the federal government. The union contracts were announced by the musicians' own representatives.
Whether a music director is worth $2.78 million, whether a CEO should earn more than eight times what a section musician earns, whether an organization should pay its general manager $2.24 million while running a $47 million deficit — those are questions for the people who buy the tickets, write the donation checks, and sit in the chairs on stage.
The data is public. The 990s are searchable. The math is arithmetic.
Sources: IRS Form 990 filings via ProPublica Nonprofit Explorer (FY ending 2024). EINs: LA Philharmonic 95-1696734, Metropolitan Opera 13-1624087, NY Philharmonic 13-1664054, Boston Symphony 04-2103550, Chicago Symphony 36-2167823, Cleveland Orchestra 34-0714468, San Francisco Symphony 94-1156284, Philadelphia Orchestra 23-1352289, Pittsburgh Symphony 25-0986052, Minnesota Orchestra 41-0693875, Detroit Symphony 38-1385132, Houston Symphony 74-1157373, Dallas Symphony 75-0705442. Musician salary sources: SFS press release (2024), AFM Local 802 (2024), AFM Local 47 (2025), WFMT (2023), CBS Philadelphia (2023), Kennedy Center (2024), International Musician, BSO press release (2023), Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (2024), Symphony.org, Seattle Symphony, Detroit News (2024). Slippedisc.com (Met musician pay, July 2025). Contractor compensation from 990 Part IX / Schedule J. Role changes verified via orchestra websites and press reporting, April 2026.
Comments
Sign in to join the discussion.